Charles-Valentin Alkan – Grande Sonate ‘Les Quatre Ages’

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Emily's Music Dump, Manka Music Group, Classic Music Blog, Charles-Valentin Alkan, Grande Sonate 'Les Quatre Ages', Robert Schumann, 1848 French Revolution, Beethoven, Zimmerman Paris Conservatoire, Antoine Marmontel, Berlioz, Gounod, Liszt, Chopin, Marc-Andre Hamelin, Charles Dutoit, Tony Faulkner, Andrew Keener, Mike Dutton, Peter Salisbury, Terry Shannon, Joanna Gamble, Mike SpringCharlies-Valentin Alkan (1813-1888)

Grande Sonate ‘Les Quatre Ages’ – Opus 33

Sonatine (Opus 61)

Barcarolle (Opus 65, No. 6)

Le Festin D’Esope (Op. 39, No. 12)

Pianist: Marc-Andre Hamelin (Hyperion)

Recorded November 23 & 24, 1994

ONE-SENTENCE REVIEW:

If Alkan do it – so can you (actually you probably can’t but Marc-Andre Hamelin comes pretty damn close in this brilliant recording)

ORIGINAL LINER NOTES [EXCERPT] (by Francois Luguenot):

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Emily's Music Dump, Manka Music Group, Classic Music Blog, Charles-Valentin Alkan, Grande Sonate 'Les Quatre Ages', Robert Schumann, 1848 French Revolution, Beethoven, Zimmerman Paris Conservatoire, Antoine Marmontel, Berlioz, Gounod, Liszt, Chopin, Marc-Andre Hamelin, Charles Dutoit, Tony Faulkner, Andrew Keener, Mike Dutton, Peter Salisbury, Terry Shannon, Joanna Gamble, Mike SpringCharles-Valentin Alkan: A Life’s Works

The Grande Sonate and Sonatine, brought together on this recording, are Charles-Valentin Alkan’s first and last masterpieces for solo piano and illustrate two extremes in the composer’s aesthetic development.

In many respects, the Grande Sonate Op. 33 is one of the pinnacles not only of Alkan’s output but of the entire Romantic piano repertoire.

In writing a piano sonata, Alkan was reviving and preserving a form which was not merely undervalued by the French but was even described by Schumann as being “worn out.”

In the hands of this extremely discreet composer, it could almost claim to be a manifesto: composed in the wake of the 1848 Revolution, and dedicated to his father, it is prefaced by what constitutes one of the rare official examples of the composer’s taking an aesthetic stand on an extremely controversial matter: programme music.

His text is not to be overlooked:

Much has been said and written about the limitations of expression through music. Without adopting this rule or that, without trying to resolve any of the vast questions raised by this or that system, I will simply say why I have given these four pieces such titles and why I have sometimes used terms which are simply never used by others.

It is not a question here, of imitative music; even less so of music seeking its own justification, seeking to explain its particular effect or its validity, in a realm beyond the music itself. The first piece is a Scherzo, the second an Allegro, the third and fourth an Andante and a Largo; but each one corresponds, to my mind, to a given moment in time, to a specific frame of mind, a particular state of the imagination. Why should I not portray it? We will always have music in some form and it can but enhance our ability to express ourselves: the performer without relinquishing anything of his individual sentiment, is inspired by the composer’s own ideas: a name and an object which in the realm of the intellect form a perfect combination, seem, when taken in a material sense, to clash with one another. So, however ambitious this information may seem at first glance, I believe that I might be better understood and better interpreted by including it here than I would be without it.

Let me also call upon Beethoven in his authority. We know that, towards the end of his career, this great man was working on a systematic catalogue of his major  works. In it, he aimed to record the plan, memory or inspiration which gave rise to each one.

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Emily's Music Dump, Manka Music Group, Classic Music Blog, Charles-Valentin Alkan, Grande Sonate 'Les Quatre Ages', Robert Schumann, 1848 French Revolution, Beethoven, Zimmerman Paris Conservatoire, Antoine Marmontel, Berlioz, Gounod, Liszt, Chopin, Marc-Andre Hamelin, Charles Dutoit, Tony Faulkner, Andrew Keener, Mike Dutton, Peter Salisbury, Terry Shannon, Joanna Gamble, Mike SpringThe composition and publication of the Grande Sonate occurred at a crucial moment in the composer’s life.

During the summer of 1848, when the Revolution was not yet over, Zimmerman, Alkan’s teacher, resigned from his position as Professor of Piano at the Paris Conservatoire.

It would seem natural enough that Charles-Valentin, his most brilliant and promising student, should succeed him; but in the troubled climate of the time, and as a result of some predictable intrigue, it was in fact a second-rate musician, Antoine Marmontel, who was to gain the post.

This was a particularly bitter pill for Alkan to swallow; he was to fade gradually further into obscurity and renounce all public and official posts.

The Revolution was also to harm any publicity which might have surrounded the publication of the Grande Sonate; although it was well heralded in the music magazines, it would appear that there was not one single review of the piece, nor one public performance thereafter.

The British pianist Ronald Smith is fully justified in thinking that he brought the piece to life in America in 1973 when he gave it its first public performance!

TRACK LISTING:

  • 1-4: Grande Sonate ‘Les Quatre Ages’ Op. 33 [38:48]
  • 5-8: Sonatine Op. 61 [18:05]
  • 9: Barcarolle Op. 65 no. 6 [3:41]
  • 10: Le Festin D’Esope Op. 39 no. 12 [8:40]

FINAL THOUGHT:

Seriously, if you’ve heard the Grande Sonate ‘Les Quatre Ages’ you would feel as I do – completely stunned that this great piano work didn’t have its public premiere until 1973. Alkan got screwed.

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Emily's Music Dump, Classical Music, Beethoven, Alfred Brendel, Czerny, Piano Sonata Opus 78, Piano Sonata Opus 106, Hammerklavier, For Therese, Alfred Brendel, Therese von Brunsvik, Josefine von Brunsvik, Queen Elizabeth Hall, Misha Donat, Franz Klein

Emily Sachs – President – Manka Music Group (A division of Manka Bros. Studios – The World’s Largest Media Company)

 

Johann Georg Albrechtsberger – Concertos for Jew’s Harp, Mandora and Orchestra

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Manka Music Group, Emily's Music Dump, Johann Georg Albrechtsberger, Concerto for Jew's Harp, Orfeo, Munich Chamber Orchestra, Hans Stadlmair, Fritz Mayr, Dieter Kirsch, Jew's Harp, Mandora, Wolfgang Schreiner, Beethoven, Joseph II, Kunert, Koch, Eulenstein, Jean Paul, Justinus Kerner, Bruno Glatzl, Melk Priory, Jacques FournierJohann Georg Albrechtsberger (1736-1809)

Concerto for Jew’s Harp, Mandora and Orchestra in E Major

Concerto for Jew’s Harp, Mandora and Orchestra in F Major

Munich Chamber Orchestra – Hans Stadlmair (Orfeo)

Recorded July 31, 1984 – Studio II des Bayerischen Rundfunks – Munich

ONE SENTENCE REVIEW:

Finally, a Jew’s Harp concerto worth listening to.

ORIGINAL LINER NOTES (including same spelling and grammar) (by Dieter Kirsch):

For many music-lovers this recording may come as something of a surprise. It is certainly a curiosity.

Who would have thought that a “common folk instrument” like the Jew’s harp (or Guimbard) had had classical concertos written for it, and by Beethoven’s teacher of composition at that!

And what is a mandora anyway?

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Manka Music Group, Emily's Music Dump, Johann Georg Albrechtsberger, Concerto for Jew's Harp, Orfeo, Munich Chamber Orchestra, Hans Stadlmair, Fritz Mayr, Dieter Kirsch, Jew's Harp, Mandora, Wolfgang Schreiner, Beethoven, Joseph II, Kunert, Koch, Eulenstein, Jean Paul, Justinus Kerner, Bruno Glatzl, Melk Priory, Jacques Fournier, Friedrich von HausenA glance at the history of the Jew’s harp will soon make us realize, however, that here we are dealing with an instrument of long and venerable lineage.

Old surviving specimens, pictures, sculptures that this is one of the most ancient and widespread of all musical instruments.

During the 19th century in Europe it even enjoyed a brief heyday outside the confines of folk music, with its own virtuoso exponents and repertoire of written works.

No other musical instrument has borne so many different names: in English Jew’s harp or Jew’s trump (origin of name unknown), in German Maultrommel (“mouth drum”) or Brummeisen (“buzzing-iron”), in Latin Crembalum, in Italian Aura (“breeze” or “breath”) and Harmonica or, again as in the poem by the minnesinger Friedrich von Hausen, “Summer” (“buzzer” or “vibrator”). This later reference would appear to be the earliest written evidence of the Jew’s harp in Europe.

From the 14th century onwards there are numerous pictorial representations of the instrument, showing it mainly in the hands of simple peasant folk but also occasionally in more august surroundings.

The cultural movement most fascinated by the sound of this strange instrument was that of the German Romantics.

After the 1800 we find more and more reports of travelling virtuosi (Kunert, Koch, Eulenstein) who were able to play on up to 16 different instruments and also in two parts. Several of the Romantic poets and novelists were so moved on hearing these excellent artists that they immortalized the instrument in their writings (e.g., Jean Paul in his novel “Hesperus”).

Justinus Kerner, the Swabian poet, physician, occultist and player of the Jew’s harp, wrote of his instrument: “Fortissimo and piano dolce can be expressed on the Jew’s harp most magnificently, and it is excellently suited for playing fantasies of one’s own; suited to convey outpourings of pure feeling in tones from better worlds, as the Aeolian harp conveys the feeling of Spring or a starry night.”

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Manka Music Group, Emily's Music Dump, Johann Georg Albrechtsberger, Concerto for Jew's Harp, Orfeo, Munich Chamber Orchestra, Hans Stadlmair, Fritz Mayr, Dieter Kirsch, Jew's Harp, Mandora, Wolfgang Schreiner, Beethoven, Joseph II, Kunert, Koch, Eulenstein, Jean Paul, Justinus Kerner, Bruno Glatzl, Melk Priory, Jacques Fournier, Friedrich von HausenThe name mandora has cropped up several times during the course of musical history.

Although the mandora of the Middle Ages is quite a different instrument from the 18th century mandora, they have one thing in common: they are both “little sisters” of the lute.

The mandora for which Albrechtsberger wrote his concerto with Jew’s harp is described in his textbook on composition (1790) under the heading “percussion instruments” as being “A small kind of lute, played in just the same manner, but tuned differently. It has only eight courses made of sheep’s gut.”

The lower four courses (pairs of strings) were tuned differently each time according to the key in which the piece was to be played. The simplification of the instrument in this way (the lute proper is an extremely difficult instrument to play) naturally results in a corresponding lack of musical substance: the player is often merely required to strum a few basic accompaniment patterns.

The similarities to the classic guitar are obvious. It is not surprising that the mandora had its greatest following among those groups of people who wanted to enjoy some convivial music-making without having too many technical demands made on them. Hence the reason why most of the surviving copies of music for mandora have been found in monastery libraries.

The history of the concerto recorded here can likewise be traced back to a monastery. In 1765, returning from his coronation in Frankfurt, Joseph II sojourned at Melk Priory.

Here he heard Father Bruno Glatzl, renowned for his virtuosity on the Jew’s harp. In the prior’s diary we can read: “lusit coram Majestatibus on two Jew’s harps. Namely, he played the Primus and the Secundus both at once, making from the notes minuets, concertos and a thousand other fine artistic things…”

A mandora provided the accompaniment.

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Manka Music Group, Emily's Music Dump, Johann Georg Albrechtsberger, Concerto for Jew's Harp, Orfeo, Munich Chamber Orchestra, Hans Stadlmair, Fritz Mayr, Dieter Kirsch, Jew's Harp, Mandora, Wolfgang Schreiner, Beethoven, Joseph II, Kunert, Koch, Eulenstein, Jean Paul, Justinus Kerner, Bruno Glatzl, Melk Priory, Jacques Fournier, Friedrich von HausenAt the time a Melk Priory scholar whose duty it was to play the organ on such festive occasions, Albrechtsberger is sure to have been present. His proficiency as an organist finally took Albrechtsberger to Vienna, where in the years that followed he composed his concertos for Jew’s harp, mandora and strings.

Judging from the numberings, Albrechtsberger must have written at least seven such concertos.

Three of them have survived, those composed in the years 1976, 1770 and 1771, and are preserved today in the Budapest National Library Szechenyi (Ms.mus 2551-2553).

All the “concerti” are autographed and prescribe the use of several Jew’s harps functioning at different pitches, whereas for the lower part Albrechtsberger employs letters without indicating exactly which octave pitch is intended. In the case of the E major concerto there exists a handwritten “viola prima” part, which, as it includes all the chief melodic material of the mandora part, is obviously intended as an alternative to this. (Dieter Kirsch – Translation: Avril Watts).

TRACK LISTING:

  1. Concerto for Jew’s Harp, Mandora and Orchestra in E major
  2. Concerto for Jew’s Harp, Mandora and Orchestra in F major

FINAL THOUGHTS:

If you can own only one Jew’s harp recording, make it this one!

piano_rating_87

Emily Sachs – President – Manka Music Group (A division of Manka Bros. Studios – The World’s Largest Media Company)

 

My Mission

Manka Bros., Khan Manka, Emily Sachs, Manka Music Group, Emily's Music Dump, CD Shelf, classical musicGood afternoon.

The purpose of this blog is to force me to listen to every single recording of music I have in my personal collection.

The bulk of this collection is classical and I am starting with those recordings in alphabetical order.

This project is going to take a couple of years as I have several thousand CDs.

I’m also going to do a slight write-up of my opinions of the piece as well as all the information on the recordings that I can muster. This will include the name, conductor, performer, cover art, etc.

Should be a fun process and if anyone would like to help contribute their opinions – that would be icing on the cake.

Emily Sachs – President – Manka Music Group (a division of Manka Bros. Studios – the World’s Largest Media Company)